Mundus Subterraneus, published in 1664, is the final result of German Jesuit scholar Athanasius Kircher’s geological investigations. Here we publish an extract from the chapter, De Lapidibus, in which Kircher muses on the cognitive phenomenon which will be later known as pareidolia – seeing faces and figures within natural formations, in this case within the cracks, veins and mineral surfaces of stones and rocks. We propose Kircher’s text as edited by Johann Beringer in his Lithographiae Wirceburgensis (1726), and later translated into English by Melvin E. Jahn and Daniel J. Woolf in The Lying Stones (1963).

Keywords:

I would recall to the reader, that, as the human phantasy, peering at the cloud-laden sky, imaginatively reads into the cloud formations a variety of things – sometimes dragons on the wing, at other times mountains, cities, or castles, again, crosses, human figures, and similar phantasmagoria – so too, even in spittle on the ground, we sometimes see a figuration of one thing or another.

 

Indeed, in our travels, gazing at mountain stretches, from a certain perspective we see a table, as the promontory of Good Hope; at other times a human face, as the promontory of Scylla in Sicily; again, a reclining man, as in the Camerino Mountain of the Apennines Mount Palermo is called Monte de Medaglia by the natives, because the stones, trees, and fragments resemble a human likeness imposed on a coin.

Sometimes on the rough surface of burnt bricks, we seem to see the outlines of insects, birds, etc. – not that Nature intended to produce such things, but by reason of a certain resemblance, the mind imagines that these things are there.

 

Reflecting on these commonplaces, one may not unreasonably ask concerning the origin of apparitions on stones.’ I answer that all these were generated by the flow of saline liquid. When this liquid seeps into appropriate earthy matter that is still soft, but is beginning to be riddled with cracks and tortuous ducts under the onslaught of desiccation, eventually, by the work of lapidific currents, all these coalesce into one hard and stony mass.

Then the liquid, following the pattern of the cracks and fissures, delineates the forms of beautiful rivers, possibly of fulsome trees, or of birds, or of insects, or quadrupeds, even a human likeness, or some member of the human body, all in accord with the dispositions of the matter […].

 

There is yet another reason, by no means a light one, supporting the formation of these apparitions by a fortuitous flow of liquid. It is that scarcely one of these images simulating animals is perfect. There is always something lacking to the full figure: an eye or nose will be missing in a head, an arm will be lacking a hand or fingers, a leg will have no foot, things which an artist would almost certainly remedy.

Wherefore, we must judge, not what, in fact, they are, but rather what the imaginative faculty pretends they are, as we said of the clouds, the mountains, the spittle, and the rest.

 

About the Author



Recent articles

Between the areas of Spitalfields and Aldgate in east London, where Middlesex and Wentworth Streets converge to form Petticoat Lane, lies a stretch of market stalls selling clothes, street food and everyday goods. This very space became the setting for a short workshop on place-writing, held in October 2023 by… Read more »

Keywords:

Every February in Southern Italy, the LGBTQ+ community gathers for a religious event at the Sanctuary of Montevergine in Mercogliano, a small village nestled in the hills of Irpinia. The group collectively enters trance-like states which celebrate “Mama”, a local medieval black Madonna who is believed to protect the marginalised…. Read more »

Keywords:

The question whether comets are habitable, and how their potential inhabitants would endure such unforgiving characteristics, was seriously considered by early modern speculators on extraterrestrial life. First published in French in 1875, this extract from Amédée Guillemin’s book “The World of Comets” (Les Comètes) summarises a few of those views,… Read more »

Keywords: